Mitch McConnell’s legacy: He destroyed the independent federal judiciary.
On Wednesday, Sen. Mitch McConnell announced that he will not seek another term as leader of the Senate Republicans, stepping down from the post (though not his seat) in January 2025. McConnell will leave a legacy of extreme obstruction, having pioneered new ways to paralyze the upper chamber in an effort to stymie Democratic legislation. He also regularly kowtowed to Donald Trump, even voting to acquit the former president following his impeachment trial over the Jan. 6 insurrection. But McConnell’s most indelible mark on history is likely to be his fixation on stacking the courts with far-right ideologues, thus fundamentally refashioning the federal judiciary in the image of the modern Republican Party.
On a new episode of Amicus, Dahlia Lithwick and Mark Joseph Stern discussed the wrecking ball that McConnell took to the independent federal judiciary and its enduring impact on American democracy and civil rights. Their conversation has been condensed and edited for clarity.
To listen to the full episode of Amicus, join Slate Plus.
Dahlia Lithwick: Can we talk about Mitch McConnell for a minute? He announced that he’s stepping down as the leader of Senate Republicans in the near future.
Mark Joseph Stern: What was your first reaction when you heard the news?
My first reaction was that I hate this timeline so much. It’s the timeline where we have to miss Rep. Kevin McCarthy because the person who followed him was, as sure as night follows day, vastly crazier. That’s how I feel about McConnell. This is the person who singlehandedly did more to destroy Senate norms of comity and respect, to help Donald Trump evade accountability, and to steal and pack the Supreme Court with people who should not be sitting on the court. And still, in this moment, we’re going to have to thank him for respecting the vestigial norms that he did and not being an utter sociopath each and every day. Because the person who follows him will be worse.
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementI’ll add that, in my view, no one has done more to destroy the federal judiciary than Mitch McConnell. This is the guy who, under Obama, decided to block as many judicial nominations as possible, for no reason other than to leave the seats open so Trump could come in and fill them. This is the guy who violated every known norm to hold open Justice Antonin Scalia’s seat, ostensibly because it came open in an election year, only to fill Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s seat when people were already votingin the 2020 election. I think he made a lot of Americans wake up and realize that this was all Calvinball, that he had no principles to begin with.
AdvertisementBut even more than that, Mitch McConnell was the guy who realized you don’t need to win elections to enact Republican policy. You don’t need to change hearts and minds. You don’t need to push ballot initiatives or win over the views of the people. All you have to do is stack the courts. You only need 51 votes in the Senate to stack the courts with far-right partisan activists like Aileen Cannon and Matthew Kacsmaryk. And they will enact Republican policies under the guise of judicial review, policies that could never pass through the democratic process. And those policies will be bulletproof, because they will be called “law,” and Democrats will need at least a century to win back the courts.
Advertisement AdvertisementAnyone who believes in an independent judiciary with any integrity should loathe McConnell to their bones.
I want to add that McConnell, for so many reasons, stands out as somebody who knew exactlywho Donald Trump was, exactly what happened on Jan. 6, exactly what his responsibility was in that moment. And he didn’t do it. He normalized the idea that you can mumble stuff and do nothing. Then we all live with the consequences. He made it easier for whoever follows him to do even less. And now he’s being praised as some elder statesman? Really? He’s totally morally bankrupt. The only silver lining, Mark, is that whoever follows him will not be as good as him at this crap.
Advertisement AdvertisementRelated From Slate
Jim Newell
Why Mitch McConnell Is Really Stepping Down in November
Read MorePopular in News & Politics
- The Lawyer Defending Idaho’s Abortion Ban Irritated the One Justice He Needed on His Side
- We’ve Been Entertaining an Illusion About the Supreme Court. It’s Finally Been Shattered.
- You Don’t Want to Know How It’s Going Between Trump’s Lawyers and the Judge Presiding Over His Criminal Case
- Prosecutors Are Finally Revealing Their Strategy Against Trump
I agree. Under Trump, McConnell built the most impressive and efficient judicial confirmation machine ever seen. He really helped to keep the broader Republican Party and conservative movement behind Trump by saying, “don’t worry, we’re still getting all the right judges!” He pushed them through at a record clip. Aileen Cannon, the judge thwarting Trump’s trial over the Mar-a-Lago documents, was confirmed after the 2020 election, when Trump had already lost! This went on right up until the end. And I don’t think his successor will match those heights, even if he or she isn’t quite as loony as we’re speculating. Think about how much Joe Biden and his team have struggled to match the number of confirmations that Trump and McConnell achieved. They can’t do it. We may have passed peak efficiency for judicial confirmations under any president.
But is that anything to celebrate? McConnell’s successor will still scrape and strive to get crazy people on the bench. And sure, they might get 20 percent fewer judges through, because they won’t have the same ruthless efficiency. But Republicans will take that deal, because it only takes one insane district court judge to thwart an entire presidency.
Tweet Share Share Comment(责任编辑:资讯)
- “笋货”上市采购旺!清远西牛麻竹笋迎秋季尝鲜热
- Here's what really happens when you call those celeb fundraising lines
- A primer on the French election: Who is running, and how it could go very bad.
- It's Prince George's first day of school and aww he looks so nervous
- [Exclusive] Samsung unsure of Suga's future as brand ambassador: source
- 应对高温 户外驿站送清凉
- An elderly man's words about his late wife reduced a shop full of people to tears
- 新技术、新模式频出!种养循环绿色技术产业化研讨会圆满举办
- Facebook warns advertisers: You might not like 'clear history'
- 10 Places to Get to Know Paul Bunyan
- On trade, Trump is flip
- Perez set to replace Albon at Red Bull
- Moon to Kim: 'Japan wants to normalize ties with North Korea'
-
本报讯近日,市教育局班子成员碰头会召开,听取近期有关工作落实情况汇报,安排部署下一步重点工作。会议要求,要狠抓工作落实,全面推进教育各项工作。全力推进川西教育中心建设,扎实开展省、市示范性普通高中、义 ...[详细]
-
Trying to swear on an iPhone is no different than trying to swear in 'The Good Place'
Swearing is impossible on NBC'sThe Good Place,but it's also impossible in this regular place we call ...[详细] -
雅安日报/北纬网成都讯1月20日下午,记者从省十二届人大五次会议雅安代表团获悉,会议期间,雅安代表团的省人大代表们在依法履职的同时,结合四川、雅安实际,积极反映人民群众的呼声和期盼,向大会提交了58件 ...[详细]
-
(Screenshot from Oh In-hye’s Instagram)Actress Oh In-hye was found unconscious in her home in the we ...[详细]
-
优化广东优质农产品产销资源对接!“农友圈”又有新动作_南方+_南方plus2023年10月,广东省农业农村厅依托“粤农技”微信小程序建成并运营了农业技术需求精准对接服务公益性平台——“农友圈”。截至7 ...[详细]
-
(Screenshot from Oh In-hye’s Instagram)Actress Oh In-hye was found unconscious in her home in the we ...[详细]
-
Premier League to trial concussion replacements, votes against five subs
LONDON:Premier League clubs on Thursday agreed in principle to introduce additional permanent concus ...[详细] -
Data scientist behind Cambridge Analytica scandal slams Facebook
The scapegoat in Facebook's ongoing data privacy scandal is firing back at the social media giant.Al ...[详细] -
Tesla reveals Cybertruck has sold more than DeLorean
If you want to know how many Cybertrucks Tesla has sold, just wait for the next recall. Two months a ...[详细] -
Women masturbating on TV and in the movies, ranked
May is National Masturbation Month, and we're celebrating with Feeling Yourself, a series exploring ...[详细]
Scientists detect water sloshing on Mars. There could be a lot.
How to use less data on your iPhone every month
- 广州市白云区供销联社携手6所院校15支队伍,加力提速推进“百千万工程”
- S. Korea welcomes opening of Afghan
- Kim's 'bitter sorrow' as bus crash kills 32 Chinese tourists [PHOTOS]
- 新技术、新模式频出!种养循环绿色技术产业化研讨会圆满举办
- 20 Places to Eat Dumplings and Noodles for Lunar New Year
- How VR porn can change the way we masturbate for the better
- Reverse cat eyeliner is the weird makeup trend du jour. Make it stop.