Scalia’s rant and Alito’s reasoning in the Fisher Supreme Court oral arguments.
As a deeply divided U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments in the latest challenge to affirmative action policies in higher education last week, the swing vote on the court—Justice Anthony Kennedy—was fairly quiet. But lines of questioning advanced by two of his colleagues—Justices Antonin Scalia and Samuel Alito—may well help tip Kennedy in one direction or the other.
Scalia and Alito are often thought of as twins on the Supreme Court—both are Italian-American conservatives, with similar names. In fact, when Alito was nominated, some people derisively referred to him as “Scalito.” But the two justices’ tactical approaches to the oral arguments in Fisher v. University of Texas II last Wednesday could not have been more different. Both justices clearly oppose the University of Texas at Austin’s policy that allows for some use of race in admissions. But at argument, Scalia denigrated the abilities of black students, which is likely to backfire with Kennedy, while Alito championed the ability of working-class black and Latino students to do well and become leaders in society—an approach far more likely to positively influence the swing justice.
Scalia’s widely reported line of questioning Texas’ lawyer, Greg Garre, which spurred a major backlash, suggested that minority students, given preference by universities, often end up struggling academically. There is a legitimate academic debate over what’s known in the literature as “mismatch”: At what point do the size of preferences (for athletes, legacies, low-income students or minority pupils) become so large that they end up putting beneficiaries in over their heads? But Scalia butchered the issue by speaking in broad strokes about the competency of black students. Using highly inflammatory language, he asked Garre whether black students might be helped by “having them go to a less advanced school … a slower-track school where they do well.” Maybe UT Austin ought to have “fewer” black students, he mused, because “when you take more, the number of blacks, really competent blacks admitted to lesser schools, turns out to be less.”
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementAlito, whose questioning has received far less media attention, took a diametrically opposed stance from Scalia. Alito showed great confidence in the abilities of minority students. Moreover, he implied that UT Austin and the Obama administration were classist in denigrating the ability of poor and working-class minority students to be leaders in American society.
Alito came out as a champion of Texas’s top-10-percent plan, which admits students in the top of every high school class in Texas, irrespective of SAT or ACT scores. The plan was adopted in the 1990s after a lower court banned the use of race at UT Austin in Hopwood v. Texas. Because Texas high schools are highly segregated by race, the plan ends up benefitting many working-class black and Hispanic students in racially isolated schools. As it turns out, the plan—coupled with a program giving an admissions boost to economically disadvantaged students of all races—eventually produced slightly more black and Latino representation than had been achieved with racial preferences prior to Hopwood.
AdvertisementBut when the U.S. Supreme Court approved racial preferences at the University of Michigan Law School in 2003, UT reinserted race into admissions. Today, three-quarters of the class is admitted through the top-10-percent plan and one-quarter through holistic admissions that consider many factors, including race. Abigail Fisher, a white student, sued in 2008 when she was denied admissions to UT Austin, saying race should not be a factor.
AdvertisementUT responded, in part, that race was necessary to admit upper-middle-class black and minority students from integrated high schools who tended not to be admitted through the top-10-percent plan. These students could serve as bridge builders and leaders, UT and the Obama administration argued. At argument, Alito pounced on this line of reasoning. When the solicitor general argued that the 10-percent plan was insufficient because the U.S. military needs diverse leaders, Alito asked: “But do you think that the African-American and Hispanic students who were admitted under the top-10-percent plan make inferior officers when compared to those who were admitted under holistic review?”
Advertisement AdvertisementIt was a brilliant question that turned the tables. If Scalia made statements that were seen by some as borderline racist, Alito put UT and the Obama administrative on the defensive for seeming to make classist assumptions about the working-class black and Latino students admitted to UT under a race-neutral policy.
Alito also pointed out that the minority strivers admitted through the top-10-percent plan do well academically. In 2000, when the 10-percent plan was in effect but racial preferences were not, UT’s president noted that “minority students earned higher grade point averages last year than in 1996 and have higher retention rates.” Moreover, careful research by Sunny Niu and Marta Tienda of Princeton University found that black and Hispanic students admitted through the percentage plan “consistently perform as well or better” than white students ranked at or below the third decile.
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementFurthermore, by stressing the virtues of the top-10-percent plan, Alito went directly to Kennedy’s key concern about affirmative action, as expressed in prior cases. Like the American public, Kennedy has been torn: He values diversity and recognizes that race still matters in American society, but he doesn’t like the idea of explicitly counting skin color in deciding who gets ahead. Programs like the top-10-percent plan and socioeconomic affirmative action disproportionately benefit black and Latino students and are precisely the types of programs Kennedy seemed to be pushing universities toward when he required, in Fisher I, that universities bear “the ultimate burden of demonstrating, before turning to racial classifications, that available workable race-neutral alternatives do not suffice.”
AdvertisementIn the oral argument, Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg faulted the 10-percent plan for relying on racial segregation, but she has it exactly backwards. As Georgetown law professor Sheryll Cashin notes, place-based approaches help “those who are actually disadvantaged by structural barriers” rather than enabling “high-income blacks to claim the legacy of American apartheid.” As I document in a new report, Achieving Better Diversity, these new alternatives to racial preferences, if properly structured, can achieve a robust socioeconomic and racial diversity that improves upon current race-based programs, which are generally limited middle- and upper-class minority students.
After last week’s oral arguments in Fisher II, it’s not certain where Kennedy is headed. It is possible that backlash against Scalia’s rant will push Kennedy to decide that now is not the time to pull the plug on racial preferences. But if Kennedy listens instead to the strong arguments advanced by Alito, he may help usher in new forms of affirmative action across the country that are fairer and recognize that bright working-class students of all races have a great deal to offer our nation.
Tweet Share Share Comment(责任编辑:行业动态)
- Elon Musk's AI facility is reportedly operating gas turbines without a permit
- Rights advocates call for renewed focus on North Korea 10 years after UN report
- Fitbit partnership brings diabetes monitoring to the Ionic smartwatch
- You can make your Samsung Galaxy S8 transparent, but there's a catch
- Trump trials: Jack Smith is reportedly reconsidering his strategy.
- Speeding space object triggered a warning. It wasn't an asteroid.
- Asiana begins Incheon
- European clubs and FIFA with odds over World Cup qualifiers
- You can make your Samsung Galaxy S8 transparent, but there's a catch
- “新丰味”喜获中国首届县域品牌擂台赛十大营销创新品牌
- Tokyo Paralympics: Haider, Anila shoulder medal hopes
- N. Korea, Russia sign protocol on sports exchanges: report
- 打造珠海海洋牧场建设精品样板工程,“格盛1号”深远海养殖平台下水
-
竹编体验本报讯8月23日,雅安市总工会2024年职工子女暑期托管班结业仪式举行,为期三周的暑期托管班落下帷幕。结业仪式上,非遗竹编手艺人冯树巍向暑期托管班孩童教授竹编技艺。在老师生动讲解下,孩子们兴奋 ...[详细]
-
European clubs and FIFA with odds over World Cup qualifiers
LONDON:European clubs have accused FIFA, the governing body of world football, of abusing regulatory ...[详细] -
N. Korean hackers ramp up efforts to funnel overseas funds into nuclear, missile programs
An average of over 1.62 million cyberattacks per day target domestic public sectorsBy Kim Hyun-binNo ...[详细] -
Experts suggest North Korea's recent silence indicates depleted weapons inventories
Russia's President Vladimir Putin shakes hands with North Korean leader Kim Jong-un at the Vostochny ...[详细] -
Norris stuns Verstappen at Dutch GP
ZANDVOORT:McLaren's Lando Norris stormed to victory at the Dutch Grand Prix Sunday, a superb dri ...[详细] -
Experts say concerns about new North Korea
Russia's President Vladimir Putin, right, and North Korea's leader Kim Jong-un attend a meeting at t ...[详细] -
Barty powers past Kerber into WTA Cincinnati final
CINCINNATI:World number one Ashleigh Barty reached her sixth final of the season on Saturday, beatin ...[详细] -
G7 foreign ministers strongly condemn N. Korea's arms transfers to Russia
The foreign ministers of the Group of Seven countries and the High Representative of the European Un ...[详细] -
Which is Faster for Gaming, Windows 10 or Windows 11?
Which is faster for gaming, Windows 10 or Windows 11? That's a question we've noticed people has kep ...[详细] -
Shirtless dudes posing with rescue dogs is your dream 2017 calendar
The 2017 edition of Heartthrobs and Hound Dogs has all the elements of a perfect calendar: Dogs in n ...[详细]
- 20 Places to Eat Dumplings and Noodles for Lunar New Year
- Messi launches 'Messiverse' NFT crypto art collection
- S. Korea confirms additional MERS case, death toll remains at 33
- NK leader oversees test
- Pixel 9 Pro XL hands
- Your headphones aren't spying on you, but your apps are. Here's why.
- Liverpool refuse to release Salah for Egypt's World Cup qualifier