The Never Trump voice vote at the GOP convention was really close.
Chaos erupted on the floor of the Quicken Loans Arena earlier today when Rep. Steve Womack (R-Ark.), in his capacity as the convention’s deputy permanent chair, called the assembled delegates to a voice vote. The issue at hand: Whether to accept the party rules drawn up last Friday by the RNC rules committee. Last week, the committee successfully fought off the Never Trump movement’s attempt to alter party rules to allow delegates to vote for the candidate of their choice rather than for the candidate to which they were bound by primary and caucus wins, a long-plotted move calculated to draw pledged delegates away from Donald Trump.
After the rules committee rejected Never Trump delegates’ so-called “conscience clause,” pre-convention reports had all but elegized the GOP holdouts, effectively declaring their effort dead on arrival. But the chorus of cheers, jeers, and boos that accompanied Womack’s call for a voice vote momentarily reinvigorated the movement’s malcontents.
The ayes (for adopting the rules) hollered, the nays (against) groused, and Womack basically cupped his hand to his ear and decided the vote “in the opinion of the chair” went for the ayes—in favor of the rules.
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementThe result was a foregone conclusion. Womack was never going to suffer a serious challenge to Trump’s ascendance—he’d already pooh-poohed a roll call vote that would have required delegates to vote individually for or against party rules.
But just how close did the Never Trump nays get? Slatedid some detective work to find out.
First, the basics: A voice vote essentially consists of screaming as loud as possible when your preferred faction is called. The chorus of ayes meant a vote for the rules. The cacophony of nays meant a vote against the rules in a last-ditch procedural measure to unseat Trump. Since there’s no way of knowing precisely how many are voting aye or nay, a voice vote is decided subjectively based which side seems louder.
AdvertisementTo figure out which bloc really earned the win, Mickey Capper, one of Slate’s podcast producers, ran the audio from the convention through a program called REAPER. The program allowed us to visualize the auditory peaks and troughs that map onto the yells, whoops, and silences of the crowd. Here’s the visual map of the vote that resulted:
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementWe then color-coded the visual to correspond to who was making noise at any given time. Yellow indicates Womack speaking, red signals those voting in favor of the rules shouting “aye,” and blue telegraphs those voting “nay.” The clip begins with Womack’s call to vote, followed by the sound of the ayes. Womack then calls for the nay vote, after which he pronounces the “ayes” the winners. We also included a fourth category, in purple, that corresponds to the reaction of the crowd after Womack called the vote in favor of the rules. The two outlier spikes that occur about 25 seconds into the minute-long clip represent the sound of Womack’s gavel following the “aye” vote.
AdvertisementBased on our analysis, Womack’s ears weren’t wrong: The “ayes” have it.
But they didn’t win by much. REAPER’s comparison of the volume and loudness of the “aye” and the “nay” votes, both visual and measured in decibels, indicates that the vote was close—very close. REAPER registered a 0.5 decibel difference between the peak of the “aye” vote (which, apart from Womack’s gaveling, was the loudest single moment in the clip and clocked in around -5.6 dB) and the peak of the “nay” vote (approximately -6.1 dB). It also registered about a one-decibel difference in sustained loudness between the two votes, with the “aye” votes taking the cake. (For a more comprehensive and technical explanation of what exactly a decibel is and how in the world they can register as negative values, we direct you here and here).
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementMickey interpreted the results of our data to me this way: Even though the “ayes” clearly won, if someone angrily asked you to turn down a too-loud television and you decreased its volume by one decibel, they’d tell you to turn it down again. It’s tough to imagine Womack’s auditory sensitivity was keen enough to detect a substantial difference in volume.
AdvertisementFurthermore, there are other aspects of our audiovisual display that look fishy if Womack’s goal was to appear impartial in calling the vote. It’s clear that Womack allowed the “ayes” to whoop, holler, and exercise in favor of the rules for about 18 seconds—two and a half times as long as he gave nay-voting delegates to do the same. This means Womack cut off “nay” voters before they could enjoy the same second-breath bump in volume that their “aye” counterparts were able to belt out after briefly trailing off around the 12-second mark. Because of the difficulty of picking up on a difference of just one decibel, it’s easy to imagine the question tipping the other way had Womack called for the “nay” vote first.
Nevertheless, the ayes, the RNC rules committee, and, by extension, Trump himself emerged victorious. But only just. The biggest takeaway? Voice voting is a pretty stupid way to figure out anything having to do with who becomes president.
Tweet Share Share Comment(责任编辑:新闻中心)
-
In 2007, Flickr was the most popular dedicated photo-sharing site on the web, and growing exponentia ...[详细]
-
万达广场人行天桥自2023年开工建设以来,进度不断加快。目前,天桥主体结构及上部雨棚等已完成建设,天桥外观效果已然呈现,工人们正忙着恢复周边道路,准备竣工验收。万达广场人行天桥建成后,可方便市民安全、 ...[详细]
-
“2024 创享未来”创友年会暨2023年度雅安市“创业明星”颁奖仪式举行
26日,“2024 创享未来”创友年会暨2023年度雅安市“创业明星”颁奖仪式举行,近六十名创业者与创业导师齐聚一堂,共赴“家宴”。此次活动旨在总结2023年创业服务工作成效,激励典型,展示创业风采, ...[详细] -
雅安茶文化宣传推广大使王霏右一)一行在北京推介展演藏茶技艺本报讯近日,国家一级茶艺和评茶技师、四川省茶艺术推广大使、雅安茶文化宣传推广大使王霏携雅安茶文化代表团队,作为四川省团队的一员,参加在首都北京 ...[详细]
-
Webb scientists haven't found a rocky world with air. But now they have a plan.
Perhaps surprisingly, the majority of stars in the galaxy are not sunclones but smaller orbs of gas ...[详细] -
本报讯1月31日,驻市委宣传部纪检监察组组织召开2023年度雅安市融媒体中心内设机构主要负责人述责述廉会议。7名内设机构主要负责人在会上作述责述廉报告,并逐一接受现场问询和质询。21名内设机构主要负责 ...[详细]
-
9月22日下午,青岛市社会保障卡“居民服务一卡通”首发暨首届社会保障卡艺术节启动仪式在青岛市市北区大鲍岛文化休闲街区广兴里举行。会议现场交通银行青岛分行发出全市首张社保卡&ld ...[详细]
-
雅安市图书馆温馨舒适的阅读环境一座城市的图书馆,代表着城市的气质,是这座城市文化的缩影,更是精神文明之花绽放的载体。近年来,雅安市图书馆坚守“传承文明、服务社会”的初心,以精神文明创建为引领,健全创建 ...[详细]
-
Pressure boost squeezes out more hydrogen from artificial leaves
Hydrogen-producing artificial leaves might soon be even better at their jobs thanks to a new study t ...[详细] -
又是一年新春到,最是岁寒情暖时。近日,雅安市综合行政执法局组成慰问组赴三区开展新春走访慰问活动,在春节前夕,将城市温度送到城市管理服务对象手中心上。一声声问候温暖人心,一声声祝福传递真情。在名山区慰问 ...[详细]