North Carolina flooding proves we need a new way of rating hurricanes
With North Carolina reeling from more than 17 inches of rain from Hurricane Matthew, it's time to face the fact that the way we measure hurricanes and communicate their likely impacts is seriously flawed.
We need a new hurricane intensity metric that more accurately reflects a storm's potential to cause death and destruction well inland, rather than the Saffir-Simpson Wind Intensity Scale, which focuses on the potential for coastal damage from high winds and storm surge flooding.
SEE ALSO:Hurricane Matthew could cause billions of dollars in U.S. economic damageSo far, Hurricane Matthew has killed 22 people in the U.S., nearly half of which occurred in North Carolina. As of midday Monday, an entire town -- Lumberton -- was being evacuated via helicopters and boats, as a river surged through the entire area. A levee break may have accelerated the flooding there.
Anthony Writebol, left, and his cousin, Melissa Hill paddle past a stranded tractor trailer on Hwy 211 in Lumberton, N.C., Sunday, Oct. 9, 2016. They were heading to meet friends who were going to let them stay after their neighborhood "wayfarer" was flooded overnight by heavy rains associated with Hurricane Matthew. (Chuck Liddy/The Charlotte Observer via AP)Credit: APThe inland flooding illustrates the complexity of these storms. In advance of the storm making landfall, the national media spotlight focused on the potential for tremendous wind and storm surge damage in Florida. Yet in the end, this event may go down in history as North Carolina's worst natural disaster on record, due to heavy rainfall.
Saffir-Simpson only measures wind
Right now, the Saffir-Simpson Hurricane Wind Intensity Scale is what we use to communicate how strong a storm is. Developed by engineer Herb Saffir and meteorologist Bob Simpson in the early 1970s, it is based on the maximum sustained winds in a hurricane.
But this ignores the multitude of other threats that hurricanes pose to coastal and inland areas. In the U.S., Hurricane Matthew, which was the longest-lasting Category 4 and 5 storm on record during the month of October, will be remembered more for its water damage -- both storm surge and inland flooding -- than its winds, which is what the Saffir Simpson Scale communicates.
Cape Fear River level and forecast crest in Fayatteville, N.C., showing sharp rise in floodwaters.Credit: NOAAWith Matthew, the storm did some of its worst damage when it was "just" a Category 1 storm, slinking along the coast of the Carolinas. The storm's category may have suggested to people that it was not a huge threat to North and South Carolina, when in fact the opposite was true.
The storm combined with a preexisting frontal system and record high amounts of atmospheric moisture, pumped into the air from unusually warm sea surface temperatures, to crank out torrential, flooding rains.
It's long been known that water is the biggest killer during hurricanes. So why do we use a scale that only communicates the wind and coastal storm surge threat?
The answer is that we just haven't come up with a better one yet. Or rather, several have been proposed, but none have become a consensus view within the weather community.
Potential alternatives
For example, a 2006 paper proposed a post-landfall hurricane classification system that would incorporate: open water storm surge, rainfall, duration of hurricane force winds, maximum sustained winds, gust score and minimum central pressure.
Each storm would be assigned numerical values for each variable, and then the storm would be assigned an overall value on a scale of 0-to-100.
Wind and water from Hurricane Matthew batter downtown St. Augustine, Fla. on Oct. 7, 2016.Credit: ohn Bazemore/APOf the Saffir-Simpson scale, the paper, which was published in the Journal of Coastal Research, stated: "Its purpose is invaluable in the pre-landfall window; however, the Saffir-Simpson Scale does not accurately account for the total damage in the post-landfall period."
The post-landfall intensity scale may have helped communicate the flood threat during North Carolina's previous record deluge from a tropical storm or Hurricane, which occurred in 1999. Hurricane Floyd caused flooding for weeks, and killed 36.
In the next week, many rivers in North Carolina are predicted to crest above the Floyd flood records due to Hurricane Matthew.
Jason Senkbell, a geography professor at the University of Alabama who co-wrote the proposal for a post-landfall hurricane classification system, said the Saffir-Simpson scale is useful because of its simplicity.
"The simple 1-5 ordinal Saffir-Simpson Scale gets people's attention and a 3 or higher usually prompts people to take protective action, or motivates those in low lying surge or flood prone areas to evacuate," he said in an email. "In this regard the Saffir-Simpson Scale has been and continues to be useful," he told Mashable, noting that new storm surge products and graphics are helping to communicate other threats that the scale does not incorporate."
The media, including meteorologists, focused a lot of attention on the threat that a Category 4 storm posed to Florida, and far less to the inland flooding prospect. This was similar to past storms, such as Hurricane Irene, which spared New York City and New Jersey much damage but went on to cause record, devastating flooding in New England.
"Every hurricane is different in terms of the types of hazards associated with landfall and we are doing a POOR job of communicating ALL hazards," Senkbell said in an email "My scale was meant to be a post-landfall scale but it could be easily adapted to be pre-landfall. Matthew would have obviously been the water danger type as soon as it left Florida."
Highway A1A, washed out by Hurricane Matthew, Saturday, Oct. 8, 2016, in Flagler Beach, Fla.Credit: Eric Gay/AP"Although several media outlets were warning for potential flooding from Matthew in the Carolinas, too much attention was devoted to the possibility of landfall on the Florida coast and the potential wind speeds above 130 mph," he said. "Matthew only had a 25% chance of making actual landfall in Florida."
Kevin Trenberth, a senior scientist at the National Center for Atmospheric Research (NCAR) in Colorado, said the Saffir-Simpson Scale "has always been seriously flawed."
However, replacing it, or supplementing it, is no easy task. "The main headline threat is always the wind speed and direct damage, which is always local to the coast," he said in an email. "The storm surge threat is also local to the coast but depends upon rate of movement of the storm and how it synchronizes with high tide: but it is always growing because sea level continues to rise," he said.
Hurricane Matthew moves along the coast of Florida on Oct. 7, 2016.Credit:"The most widespread threat is heavy rains and flooding," he said, noting that the size of the rainfall threat is related to the size of the storm and the temperature of the ocean where the storm is drawing its energy from.
With Hurricane Matthew, Trenberth said the sea surface temperatures were more than 2 degrees Celsius, or 3.6 degrees Fahrenheit, above average for this time of year, across a broad region that the storm drew moisture from.
This added more water vapor to the air, which eventually condensed and fell as torrential rain in the Carolinas.
"So it seems to me that three threats need to be assessed but often aren't, or not adequately," Trenberth said.
Another index that has been proposed is the Cyclone Damage Potential, or CDP. This one can be used to estimate the potential damage a storm will cause to offshore facilities. Greg Holland, a researcher at NCAR who helped develop the scale, says work is ongoing to try to extend it to onshore impacts as well.
"The Saffir-Simpson categories are an excellent approach to providing clear communication on the potential impacts of hurricanes of varying intensity. However, while intensity is very important, focusing on it alone may lead to miscommunication of the actual impact potential," he said in an email.
Rainfall totals in NC, SC and Va. from Hurricane Matthew.Credit: NOAAThere are still other proposals out there, including a scale that would try to capture the force and area of a storm's wind field, known as Integrated Kinetic Energy, or IKE.
Each of these has its pros and cons, but no single scale has yet been agreed upon and moved forward to an implementation. Hurricane Matthew should be a wakeup call that this needs to happen, soon.
With climate change set to increase rainfall from these massive storms, developing a more impacts-focused hurricane scale that includes the inland flooding issue is going to be even more critical.
Such a scale, if it is successful, could save lives, and prevent people from being caught off guard by torrential, even catastrophic amounts of rain.
Perhaps the people of North Carolina -- many of whom have told reporters they were caught off guard by the flooding -- will have some suggestions, once they get through this ordeal.
(责任编辑:关于我们)
-
11 Unique Amaros and Liqueurs to Level Up Your Aperol Spritz
Spritzes, made of sparkling wine, soda water, and amaro, have become synonymous with summer in the U ...[详细] -
入春以来,苹果、柚子等冬季水果逐渐告别舞台,春夏时令水果方面,国产与进口两大品类共同争抢市场份额,岛城水果市场愈发热闹。记者近日探访发现,新鲜时令水果受到越来越多消费者的喜爱,为抢占市场份额,不少进口 ...[详细]
-
日前,第三届重庆避暑旅游文化节在观音桥商圈步行街盛大举行。这一次避暑旅游文化节亮点多多,避暑方式也多种多样。雅安在旅游文化节上推出五大不同风格的旅游线路,吸引游客目光。大熊猫文化探秘之旅大熊猫,被誉为 ...[详细]
-
“连平·忠信花生”点亮广州塔,是河源农产品品牌首例_南方+_南方plus好事“花”生,丰收连平!11月25日晚,河源“连平·忠信花生”亮相广州塔。(河源“连平·忠信花生”亮相广州塔,时长共30秒)秋收 ...[详细]
-
“至正七年置”青花纪年铭文盖罐1939年,梁思成考察测绘高颐阙 资料图片成都矛石羊上石兽一座古老城市的背后往往是一篇绵延的历史长诗,人类开始学会直立行走,同其他类人猿逐渐划分开伊始,部落、城邦在漫长的 ...[详细]
-
认捐100棵树!白云山云台花园“园长”为绿美广东代言_南方+_南方plus(认捐100棵树!白云山云台花园“园长”为绿美广东代言,时长共1分06秒)作为南粤名山之一,白云山自古有“羊城第一秀”之称,景 ...[详细]
-
近日,2016年第一季度最受关注家居数码品牌TOP50数据显示,HOLA特力和乐家居排名位居第一。据大数据中心报告指出,从整体家居类业态的品牌关注度以及商业招商营运实践来看,家居类业态整体与生活品质、 ...[详细]
-
广垦畜牧刘世坤:围绕种业发展的主题,广垦与广东养猪产业大会共发展
广垦畜牧刘世坤:围绕种业发展的主题,广垦与广东养猪产业大会共发展_南方+_南方plus广东广垦畜牧集团股份有限公司以下简称“广垦畜牧”)是广东省农垦集团公司旗下以养殖业尤其是养猪业为主的全产业链集团, ...[详细] -
“至正七年置”青花纪年铭文盖罐1939年,梁思成考察测绘高颐阙 资料图片成都矛石羊上石兽一座古老城市的背后往往是一篇绵延的历史长诗,人类开始学会直立行走,同其他类人猿逐渐划分开伊始,部落、城邦在漫长的 ...[详细]
-
雅安日报/北纬网讯日前,记者从市经信局获悉,近日,四川省文化和旅游厅、四川省经济和信息化厅公布了第一批四川省传统工艺振兴目录共88项。其中,我市的全手工工艺软包皮拖鞋制作技艺、荥经砂器烧制技艺、南路边 ...[详细]