Experts advise caution over rush to declare end to Korean War
With the two Koreas marking the 65th anniversary of signing the armistice agreement of the Korean War, the focus is now on whether they can realize their plan of declaring an official end to the war by the end of this year.
The two Koreas have been pushing for a formal end to the war since President Moon Jae-in and North Koreas leader Kim Jong-un pledged to replace the armistice agreement with a peace treaty at the Panmunjom summit in April.
But the idea should be pursued with caution and in conjunction with progress in North Korea’s denuclearization efforts, experts said, noting that a relentless pursuit of ending the Korean War could undermine South Korea and the US’ efforts to make Pyongyang give up its nuclear program.
“Declaring an end to the Korean War without significant progress on denuclearization is a grave mistake,” said Shin Beom-chul, a senior fellow at the Asan Institute for Policy Studies, a Seoul-based research institute.
“It must happen at least when North Korea has declared its nuclear facilities. Otherwise, we could end up paying too high a price for North Korea’s trivial denuclearization measures.”
Shin asserted it is really a “bad idea” to agree to declare an end to the Korean War in return for North Korea’s reported decision to dismantle the missile engine test site at Sohae Satellite Launching Station.
Over the past few weeks, North Korea’s state-run media have called for declaring an end to the Korean War, describing the measure as a prerequisite for defusing cross-border tension and establishing a peace regime on the Korean Peninsula.
Pyongyang has also accused the United States of delaying the process by making unilateral demands on denuclearization, urging South Korea to play a more active role in adopting a declaration of the Korean War this year.
Analysts said if Seoul attempts to broker a peace treaty with North Korea through the declaration of the Korean War, South Korea would become more vulnerable to North Korea as it would undermine the US troop presence in South Korea.
“I think a peace treaty would be well-intentioned, but anything with the word ‘peace’ in it while North Korea’s nuclear posture remains unchanged is a dangerous joke,” said Van Jackson, a former Pentagon official who teaches at Victoria University of Wellington in New Zealand.
“For reasons of US politics, the alliance commitment would effectively end if a peace treaty came about. The US could live with that, but could South Korea?” Jackson said. “Maybe Moon is secretly OK with the end of the alliance, though for political reasons he could never admit it.”
The Moon administration noted that it wants to declare an end to the Korean War as soon as possible within this year, suggesting that the event could occur even before North Korea completely abandons its nuclear arsenal.
According to Cheong Wa Dae and Cabinet members, the declaration could prompt North Korea to step up denuclearization efforts, as it offers a political guarantee for North Korea’s security concerns amid the denuclearization negotiations.
Unification Minister Cho Myung-kyun reiterated the idea during his meeting with lawmakers Tuesday. Asked whether the declaration could come about before North Korea’s denuclearization, Cho acknowledged it is quite likely.
“It is quite ambiguous to say which one should come first,” Cho said, responding to lawmakers’ question about where priorities should be placed between declaring an end to the Korean War and North Korea’s complete denuclearization.
“(Declaration of an end to the Korean War) can play a role in facilitating the denuclearization process and I think we can pursue the idea even before North Korea completely abandons its nuclear program … it is more of a political declaration and there are no legal measure involved.”
Expectations had been high that the two Koreas and the US would declare an end to the Korean War following the first-ever US-North Korea summit in April. Cheong Wa Dae even envisioned a scenario where President Moon would fly to Singapore for a trilateral agreement.
Now that the Singapore summit has ended without such an agreement, speculation has been rampant that the Moon administration is now seeking to make the declaration as early as August and involve China in the process along with the US.
Some analysts suggest the declaration could take place at the UN General Assembly session in September --provided that Kim Jong-un manages to make his first trip to the UN and meets with Moon, Trump and Chinese leader Xi Jinping.
“Considering the fact that declaration of an end to the Korean War is only a political measure, its implications can be maximized during a meeting with national leaders,” said Cho Seong-ryoul, a senior researcher at the Institute for National Security Strategy.
Regarding the Chinese participation in declaring an end to the Korean War, the Moon administration appears to embrace the idea. China is a signatory to the armistice agreement, though South Korea is not.
During a meeting with lawmakers on Wednesday, Foreign Minister Kang Kyung-wha said China is “an important partner to work with on the Korean issue,” hinting that China could be involved with the efforts to officially end the Korean War.
Regardless of the extent of China’s involvement, experts noted that South Korea should be cautious about the possibility that Beijing may use it as an opportunity to push its own agenda.
“(China’s participation) is not necessary. The two Koreas could declare an end to the war. But for a peace treaty to be signed, China would have to be involved, along with the US and North Korea,” Ken Gause, director of the International Affairs Group at CNA, a Virginia research group.
“I don’t think that is North Korea’s intention (to weaken the South Korea-US alliance through the declaration), but I do agree that we need to be aware that such actions would be something that support China’s national interests. The US should refrain from any discussion about removing troops from the peninsula.”
By Yeo Jun-suk(jasonyeo@heraldcorp.com)
(责任编辑:产品中心)
- 多措并举优治理 绘就幸福新图景
- North Korean restaurants in China to resume business
- 潮汕味,世界享!汕头美食亮相预制菜“第一会”
- N. Korea urges Japan to work past wrongdoings
- 味道真系正!怀集食材邂逅顺德厨艺
- “精致小春姐”顾春芳:华丽白西装、镶钻水晶拖鞋,带来新兴凉果No.1
- 'Not easy'
- South Korean military holds boosting frontline military bases
- North Korea leader asks to protect forest in border region
- Scientists discover where the huge dinosaur
- Stones must improve fitness record: Guardiola
- X makes Taylor Swift's name unsearchable amid viral deep fakes
- Best Apple Watch deal: Get an Apple Watch Series 9 for 27% off
-
Speeding space object triggered a warning. It wasn't an asteroid.
It's good to know that our planetary defense systems work. The European Space Agency revealed that o ...[详细] -
29日 2014春季广州茶博会开幕 我市13家茶企将组团参加
雅安日报讯5月29日,2014春季中国(广州)国际茶业博览会将在广州市琶洲·中洲中心举行,展会总面积达35,000平方米,将有来自中国内地20多个省(直辖市、自治区)、中国港澳台地区以及马来西亚、韩国 ...[详细] -
MrBeast earns more than $250,000 on video uploaded to Elon Musk's X
If you've been on Elon Musk's X anytime over the past week, you've likely seen MrBeast fill up your ...[详细] -
Best wildlife spotting deal: Get the Birdfy Feeder for under $150
SAVE $70: The Birdfy Feeder is just $149.99, marked down from its normal price of $219.99. That's a ...[详细] -
You're playing the latest Call of Mario: Deathduty Battleyardon your perfect gaming PC. You're looki ...[详细]
-
New AirPods Pro with ‘Year of the Dragon’ engraving are here. But there’s a catch.
Apple is selling some reallycool-looking AirPods Pro right now, but you may not be able to buy them. ...[详细] -
Police to question labor union members over alleged assault
Police on Thursday called for seven unionized workers of a local auto parts maker to appear for ques ...[详细] -
X makes Taylor Swift's name unsearchable amid viral deep fakes
Pornographic deepfakes of Taylor Swift went viral on X (formerly Twitter) this week, highlighting th ...[详细] -
South Korean lawmakers brace for US election as Harris, Trump diverge on North Korea
Democratic presidential nominee and US Vice President Kamala Harris waves from the stage on Day 4 of ...[详细] -
吴友安右)与搬迁巡查队队员交换意见“七哥,又准备到搬迁户家里谈事情啊?”10日14时许,从北外环线工程拆迁办出来的吴友安,遇见前来准备签订搬迁协议的一户群众。“有几个已签订协议的搬迁户马上就要倒房了, ...[详细]
- Pope says England are not 'one
- LinkedIn stalking is low key the biggest thing in online dating
- 学习灾区经验 指导工作开展
- This 1 piece of crucial English speaking advice is sending the internet wild
- Blinken condemns Russia
- Cho urged to step down over misconduct allegations against Blue House audit team
- “三公”支出只减不增 办公用房、公车使用严格管理