This new breastfeeding help chatbot frustrates more than it informs
Nursing a baby at 3 a.m. – especially when it's not going well – can lead you down a Google rabbit hole. When all you want is for your baby to stop crying so you can both get back to sleep, getting hold of reliable and relevant information as soon as possible is vital.In an effort to help out new nursing parents at exactly this dark hour, Public Health England (PHE) has launched an interactive Facebook Messenger chatbot to encourage longer breastfeeding relationships.
SEE ALSO:This breast pump is legit quiet enough to use on a conference callIn a blog post announcingthe chatbot, PHE chief executive Duncan Selbie said the UK has the lowest rate of breastfeeding mothers in the world, but the "right support" can keep mums breastfeeding for longer. The Start4Life BreastFeeding Friend chatbot – BFF for short – aims to address this need for support with a tool that's accessible during the wee hours when healthcare professionals aren't available. This bot, as it turns out, probably won't give you the support you require."New babies need to be fed round the clock, and the peak times for online searches for breastfeeding help (by volume over 24 hours) are 2 and 6 a.m., when healthcare professionals and ‘phone helplines are not readily available," a spokesperson for PHE explained.Good point, and it makes sense to have around-the-clock access to trusted information. But the limitations of the bot are in how the information is obtained, not when.
When you're a new parent, a lot of the questions you have are general – Why is my baby crying? How do I know if the baby is hungry?When you ask those questions, either to a person or the internet, you need to get back answers that are robust. Alas, this chatbot won't give them to you.The main problem seems to lie in the bot's ability – or lack thereof – to process natural language. If you ask the bot a general question in sentence form, you will not get the answer you're looking for.
Credit: rachel thompson / mashableThe bot responds best when presented with shorter phrases and keywords, which will automatically throw up two or three paragraphs of advice. But being automated, it's limited in the number of keywords it responds to and you won't always get answers to questions that are specific enough to deal with your individual experience.
Getting the most appropriate answer seems entirely dependent on knowing the exact question, which requires a level of knowledge that new parents might not have. And attempting to ask the perfect question while sleep deprived and emotional in the face of a crying baby seems like a rather miserable game, to put it mildly.
Case in point, asking "How many times a day should I nurse?" doesn't get you an answer. That's only one of the most basic questions a new nursing mom would have. You know, NBD.
Credit: rachel thompson / mashableThat said, there are solid step-by-step guides for latching on, expressing milk and introducing bottles, in addition to tips for feeding with and storing expressed milk. There's advice for increasing your milk supply, as well as information on things that can affect your supply and tips for stopping feeding. The FAQs are helpful. In fact, skipping the "conversation" and just checking those out is a pretty good way to go.
Credit: start4life / mashableThe bot provides easily-accessible basic advice on a platform where new mums are already likely to be. If you're one-handedly talking to a friend or family member on Messenger, then it's easy to fire off a message to the bot. But you'll very quickly run into the bot's limits and probably end up asking a human being for the information you need. Currently the bot isn't a substitute for the wealth of information that friends, family and medical professionals can provide; information that's backed up with a huge amount of personal experience.Parenting startup CEO Vivien de Tusch-Lec tried out the new bot to get some advice on phasing out breastfeeding. "It gave me the advice I needed. It took a little while to get there, but not as long as trawling through myriad Google search results," says de Tusch-Lec.But de Tusch-Lec says she was left with more questions the bot was unable to answer. Despite this, she found it helpful for getting consistent and authoritative views and says she wishes it had existed when she started breastfeeding. "It’s also useful as a quick reference tool where info is finely filtered according to questions, so ultimately I found it more accurate than other ways of finding info," she continued.
Credit: START4LIFE / RACHEL THOMPSON/ MASHABLEKay Brown – who runs a baby and toddler groupfor mums in the digital sector – says she's on the fence as to whether the chatbot is a good idea. "One of the greatest struggles when breastfeeding is getting the correct latch and a suitable position and this isn’t something a chatbot can tell or give you direct support with," Brown says.But, freelance PR Gina Clarke – who breastfed both her children for a year – says she was desperately in need of something like this chatbot. "Health visitor appointments could take days so I would often hang on for the breastfeeding helpline opening at 6am, but because it's staffed by volunteers I could rarely get through and had to turn to Dr Google quite a lot," says Clarke. At the same time, however, Clarke thinks that the bot is no replacement for IRL human support. "It certainly shouldn't replace the health visitor as the human voice, but having some instant support would have been incredibly handy when I was breastfeeding," Clarke continues.The chatbot is a great resource for providing trusted and instant advice for breastfeeding FAQs and it's certainly quicker and more reliable than trawling through Google. But, in its current state, it just doesn't go far enough to provide nuanced information for new mums who are figuring out how to do something they don't know how to do. For the time being, you're better off just heading to the NHS' breastfeeding website.
Featured Video For You
This breast pump is quiet enough to use on a conference call
TopicsFacebookFamily & Parenting
(责任编辑:新闻中心)
-
'Please find her': Man dies amid 25
Song Gil-yong speaks during a public campaign dedicated to finding his missing daughter, Hye-hee, in ...[详细] -
近日,宝兴灵关重建委整合社会公益组织力量,在灵关片区安置点设立了儿童乐园和夕阳之家,为受灾老人群体和儿童群体提供健身、棋牌等文体活动。同时,每周一天为50岁以上的老人进行量血压、测心率等简单的免费体检 ...[详细]
-
汉源二中举行高2010级“百日冲刺”誓师大会雅安日报讯“用我们最强的干劲,最好的教学效果,最合适的教学手段,全身心地扑入到高三教学和管理中去。高三我们同舟共济!”2月27日,汉源二中举行高2010级“ ...[详细]
-
贵州茅台捐赠公益资金300万元支持我市600名贫困学生圆大学梦
雅安日报讯近日,经团市委协调争取,贵州茅台习酒有限公司捐赠公益资金300万元,支持我市600名考取二本以上的贫困大学新生,进一步动员社会各界力量帮助贫困大学生实现大学梦,弘扬助人为乐、捐资助学的良好风 ...[详细] -
We Bought the Cheapest DDR5 RAM Modules We Could Find, Are They Any Good?
For this article we're doing something simple: find the cheapest DDR5 RAM we could get our hands on, ...[详细] -
雅安日报讯7月31日早6时40分,一辆从成都开往凉山会理的货车,在雅西高速公路石棉收费站附近时,尾部突然起火,导致全车价值近50万元的货物烧了个精光。“接到报警后,我们三分钟赶到现场,只见一辆货车被大 ...[详细]
-
雅安日报讯日前,荥经县召开2013年县委中心组第一次学习会,重点学习了中央一号文件精神以及城镇化与我国新时期改革的中心任务等内容。为推进全县传统砂器产业的健康有序发展,实现荥经砂器文化的振兴,推动荥经 ...[详细]
-
5月25日,名山区法院大门前响起一阵鞭炮声,划破城区街道周末的宁静。余霜一家四口从乡下经过一个多小时的辗转颠簸赶到法院,一边道谢一边给法官送上写着“公正司法 维护正义”的锦旗。余霜更是激动不已,她说, ...[详细]
-
Noelle Mateer ,July 17, 2024 The Techies W ...[详细]
-
“花果山”变成“采石场”说起冷木沟,宝兴县城的群众无不扼腕叹息。“沟里溪水清澈见底,村里有樱桃、枇杷、桃子、李子。春季赏花,夏季品果,秋看枫叶,冬观白雪。完全就是我们宝兴人民的‘花果山’。只可惜全毁在 ...[详细]