Google, Apple say no to UK intelligence agency’s plan to listen in on encrypted chats
Google, Apple, Microsoft, WhatsApp and numerous other companies and organizations have publicly opposed a proposal by the UK's intelligence agency GCHQ to open up encrypted communication to the government.
In an open letter to GCHQ, dated May 22, the group addresses a proposal published by GCHQ in November 2018. While the letter says that the "principles set forth by GCHQ officials are an important step in the right direction," it criticizes the proposal for “silently adding a law enforcement participant to a group chat or call,” also referred to as the "ghost proposal."
Essentially, the GCHQ wants messaging services such as Facebook's Messenger, WhatsApp and Signal to put in a switch that would enable the UK government to snoop on any encrypted chat. And while the GCHQ's proposal insists this is "not about weakening encryption or defeating the end-to-end nature of the service," Google, Apple and other signees of the letter claim that such a proposal would "pose serious threats to cybersecurity and thereby also threaten fundamental human rights, including privacy and free expression."
The letter lists several reasons why the ghost proposal is a horrible idea. It undermines the authentication process and it could introduce new (unintentional) security flaws into encrypted communication systems. It would also undermine users' trust into such systems, and opens up new avenues for abuse -- would you trust your encrypted chat to be really private if you knew there could be a government official reading every word you wrote?
In conclusion, the signees of the letter urge GCHQ to abandon the ghost proposal, as well as "avoid any alternate approaches that would similarly threaten digital security and human rights."
Besides the tech giants listed above, the signees of the open letter include civil society organizations like the Electronic Frontier Foundation and Human Rights Watch, as well as several security experts.
In response, Ian Levy, one of the authors of the proposal, told The Guardian that "we welcome this response to our request for thoughts on exceptional access to data -- for example to stop terrorists. The hypothetical proposal was always intended as a starting point for discussion. We will continue to engage with interested parties and look forward to having an open discussion to reach the best solutions possible.”
Featured Video For You
Facebook reveals its 'privacy-focused vision for social networking'
(责任编辑:关于我们)
- Our galaxy might crash into Andromeda. What would happen to Earth?
- 市安委会召开今年第四次全体成员会议
- Moon gov't losing ground in NK
- Generous man spends daughter's wedding money to build houses for the homeless
- Update your BIOS: Utilities from Top Motherboard Makers
- How much will PCB's Champions Cup mentors be paid?
- Cambridge Analytica used self
- Evernote reverses controversial privacy policy but damage is already done
- PGA Tour boosts prize money
- The Techies Who Lunch
- Gov't to provide support for over 500 North Korean defectors facing tough living conditions
- 和美乡村过大年,邀请您到全国休闲农业重点县英德来
- 7th grade boy nails his extra credit question by telling the best joke
-
评论丨农事运动会:一场农民的盛会、新农人风采展现的盛会、城乡双向奔赴的盛会
评论丨农事运动会:一场农民的盛会、新农人风采展现的盛会、城乡双向奔赴的盛会_南方+_南方plus广东省农事运动会火了,周末两天5场农事活动,场场都成为热搜话题。青瓦村屋旁、乡土大地上,来自广东各地的城 ...[详细] -
N.K. unveils footage of restaurant defector family members
North Korea on Thursday unveiled video footage in which the parents of one North Korean restaurant w ...[详细] -
5 things to do right now if your Yahoo account was hacked
If you've just logged into your Yahoo email and read an urgent security letter from the Yahoo team s ...[详细] -
2 activists have won the Nobel Peace Prize for their work to end sexual violence
Activists Nadia Murad and Denis Mukwege, who are working to end rape and sexual violence as weapons ...[详细] -
Washington Mystics vs. Chicago Sky 2024 livestream: Watch live WNBA
TL;DR:Watch Washington Mystics vs. Chicago Sky in the WNBA with WNBA League Pass. Avoid blackouts an ...[详细] -
5 things to do right now if your Yahoo account was hacked
If you've just logged into your Yahoo email and read an urgent security letter from the Yahoo team s ...[详细] -
Tennis star Svitolina helping Ukraine
PARIS:Former women's tennis world number three Elina Svitolina has told AFP she hopes one day to ...[详细] -
大渡河和流沙河在汉源县交汇。交汇处,有一平坝,名曰娃娃营。交汇处的三面,一面是建设汉源新县城的萝卜岗,一面是炒米岗,还有一面则是建设大树新集体的山羊坪。新修建的大树大桥将炒米岗和山羊坪连接起来。 1 ...[详细]
-
Which is Faster for Gaming, Windows 10 or Windows 11?
Which is faster for gaming, Windows 10 or Windows 11? That's a question we've noticed people has kep ...[详细] -
Generous man spends daughter's wedding money to build houses for the homeless
In a deviation from the norm, a wealthy businessman in India chose to celebrate his daughter’s ...[详细]
- Essential Apps to Install on your Windows PC or Mac
- In her first official statement, Kim's sister slams South Korea
- KFC Japan offers two
- Footage of 'inhumane' treatment of jailed Aboriginal woman rattles Australia
- “新丰味”喜获中国首届县域品牌擂台赛十大营销创新品牌
- 荥经县:群众举报 非法飙车遭起
- 5 things to do right now if your Yahoo account was hacked