Wikimedia is against European Parliament's Copyright Directive
On Thursday, the European Parliament rejected a controversial proposal to overhaul the European Union's copyright laws that critics say would significantly damage internet freedom.
The legislation — dubbed the Copyright Directive — was rejected by a vote of 318-278. That means the proposed rules, which passed the European Parliament's legal branch last month, will now be debated in September.
The proposal is an attempt to modernize copyright laws for the digital age, and its proponents — which include high-profile musicians like David Guetta and Paul McCartney — say it will protect artists from having their work stolen on the internet. But its opponents fear the bill will open the door for widespread censorship.
The directive would require sites like Facebook and YouTube to have paid licenses before they could link to people's creative content (articles, videos, etcetera), which would heavily stymie what information gets to people.
And the laws would additionally apply an algorithmic filter on any content uploaded to the internet, which would also put parody and satire (read: our memes and gifs) on the line.
And the way we know and love Wikipedia now — one of the largest open-source forums — would be on the line as well.
Wikimedia, which owns around a dozen other open-source forums like Wikipedia, issued a statement last week against the directive, which highlighted main points of concern against the Copyright Directive.
Its board of trustees, which consists of heavyweight tech execs like Quora chief financial officer Kelly Battles and former Gizmodo Media Group chief executive Raju Narisetti, outlined three main grievances in its statement, which is part of a string of open pushes Wikimedia and its properties have made against the proposed legislation.
Wikimedia's entire empire is built off open-sourcing — it calls itself "the world's largest online repository of free knowledge" — and its board claimed that the proposed laws contradict the platform's goal to make knowledge free and accessible to everyone.
The new restrictions, if passed, would possibly lead to a loss of revenue for the giant as well, since its funding mainly relies on user contributions. With a restricted reach after the proposed laws, the funding would probably also fall.
SEE ALSO:Europe considers internet copyright law that would kill your favorite GIFs and memes"If passed, it would limit free expression, and cause serious harm to collaboration and diversity online," reads the statement. "Instead of truly modernizing copyright for Europe and promoting everyone's participation in information society, the proposal threatens freedom online and creates new obstacles to access by imposing new barriers, filters, and restrictions."
The company added, "[The laws], if enacted, will significantly limit the openness of the internet, diminishing the ability of people around the globe to access knowledge, while stifling innovation and imposing what we believe will be unreasonable costs on new or smaller websites."
Stephen LaPorte, a legal counsel for the Wikimedia Foundation, told Mashablethat although it's important to keep copyright infringed material offline, algorithms that vet information will not do people's content justice.
"The problem the EU Parliament is faced with is how to create a space online that protects and protects people like us from copyright infringements," LaPorte said. "The laws need to reflect the way people actually use or want to use the internet. It needs to show how users are creators and not just consumers of content."
He said it was concerning that the laws envisioned using algorithms (similar to the one YouTube uses) to filter all uploaded content, which would possibly lead to censorship of criticisms and parodies.
An algorithm would not have the capacity to distinguish between stolen copyrighted material versus creative content using copyrighted material to progress the conversation. Think of it like a robot teacher that can identify when students reference other people's work in an essay but cannot contextualize that the quote is used as a citation.
Only people, LaPorte said, have the capacity to vet information for actual copyright infringement without censorship of creative works.
Although the laws are designed for people sharing content within the E.U., the large population of internet users within the Schengen Zone would lead to worldwide content freedom changes.
Infringing on the freedom of expression
Think of the proposed law like YouTube's anti-copyright infringement filter, which was implemented to make sure that no content on its platform steals from any other creator's work.
It has previously taken down all types of copyright infringement free videos, such as Greenpeace's Star Wars parody video and the French political party Front National had its entire channel taken down last month.
Now take that anti-copyright infringement filter and apply it to the entire internet.
While it sounds proactive, the mandate could have hefty privacy and freedom of expression repercussions.
"These battles are frankly not transparent and restrict people's ability to communicate," LaPorte said. "It contradicts with the vision for the internet."
That means sharing and social platforms would be drastically changed: What would happen to Twitter if only people who had the rights to an image could retweet it? What happens to live tweeting the Grammys when we can't post Blue Ivy shushing Jay Z and Beyoncé? To anyone who shares a Spongebob meme that isn't Viacom?
Harm collaboration
Crippling collaboration probably hits home the hardest for Wikimedia and its various properties.
Almost anyone can edit the countless forum pages on its subsidiaries like Wikipedia, Wiktionary, and Wikinews. They basically cover broad-sweeping categories of culture, which are almost all based off creative work.
Using and accessing these sites could possibly become restricted if the copyright laws as written had passed, which would not only have stymied the freedom of sharing information, but it would have also omitted a large chunk of contributors.
Ruin diversity online
Increased restrictions of who may share content (due to licensing issues the new laws would have established) would limit how far information and knowledge could travel.
If everyone does not have an accessible way to contribute to Wikipedia — or any of Wikimedia's properties for that matter — the diversity of voices contributing to the forums would drop considerably.
News would also have limited impact if who is allowed to share the creative content was restricted, and this restrained scope would heighten the internet echo chambers that are critiqued around the world.
"It's such a good opportunity to strike a balance between copyright and more restrictions," LaPorte said. "I feel like this is not that balance."
Correction: A previous version of this article incorrectly stated that Wikia is part of the Wikimedia Foundation. The claim has since been removed.
Featured Video For You
Mars will be super close to Earth this summer
(责任编辑:产品中心)
-
We Cannot Live Without Cryptography!
You're about to wind up your day and use your smartphone to check what's in your smart fridge to dec ...[详细] -
雅安日报讯日前,四川省教育考试院在其官方网站上公布《四川省教育考试院关于做好2012年普通高校专科层次招生补录工作的通知》(以下简称《通知》),我省将在9月下旬进行一次专科层次补录工作,时间是9月24 ...[详细]
-
雅安日报讯按照《荥经县推进应用房地产评估技术加强存量房交易税收征管工作实施方案》要求,荥经县地税局采取切实有效措施,积极推进应用房地产估价技术加强存量房交易税收征管各项工作,从9月1日起,房地产交易价 ...[详细]
-
大假归来记得给爱车做保养车身怎么被烟花爆竹炸伤了?轮胎跑着跑着咋会跑偏呢?这奇怪的声响是从哪儿传出来的?糟糕,刹车油不够了……春节大假,长途跋涉,爱车经历雨打风吹,各种复杂的路况难免有些磕磕碰碰。所以 ...[详细]
-
Alcaraz vs. Van de Zandschulp 2024 livestream: Watch US Open for free
TL;DR:Live stream Alcaraz vs. Van de Zandschulp in the 2024 US Open for free on 9Now or TVNZ+. Acces ...[详细] -
雅安日报讯昨(10)日,是我国第28个教师节。在这个感恩的日子里,参加了今年伦敦奥运会的我市芦山县运动健儿余成刚,回到了他的母校雅安市雨城区第二中学,探望了阔别已久的恩师,并送上了他对母校的真挚祝福— ...[详细]
-
雅安日报讯近日,石棉县人民检察院在办理吉某某等人盗窃一案时,承办检察官发现,该案中原本没有被起诉的司机罗某某有涉嫌盗窃罪的证据,随即对其依法予以追加起诉。今年1月29日,犯罪嫌疑人吉某某等人盗窃了雅泸 ...[详细]
-
雅安日报讯7日下午,名山县教育局组织全县各中小学、教师进修校、蒙阳镇幼儿园等校(园)长和局机关中层以上干部,学习传达党的十八大精神。县教育局局长彭星智要求,全县广大教职员工要把学习贯彻十八大精神作为当 ...[详细]
-
22 Unusual Things You Can Find in the Desert
In the desert, it can seem like very little exists aside from dunes and a few creatures that are ada ...[详细] -
民警在事故现场搜寻肇事残留物11月20日凌晨,雨城区飞机坝发生一起电动车与自行车相撞后电动车逃逸的交通肇事逃逸案件,伤者经医院抢救无效死亡。市公安局交警支队特勤大队值班民警接报后,迅速展开调查搜捕工作 ...[详细]