After Florida shooting, gun control becomes a global conversation
When you move to America from a country with more effective gun control laws, one of the first things you learn is how hard it is to talk to Americans -- even on the sympathetic side of the political divide -- about the gun issue.
It was particularly difficult when I arrived on these shores in 1996, direct from living in Scotland during its (and Britain's) worst-ever school shooting. In the tiny town of Dunblane, a 43-year old former shopkeeper and scoutmaster brought four handguns to a school gymnasium full of five-year-olds. He shot and killed 16 of them and their teacher, then turned his handgun on himself.
SEE ALSO:These books will make you think differently about the gun control debateAfter Dunblane, the British plunged into a state of collective mourning that was at least as widespread as the better-known grieving process for Princess Diana the following year. (Americans don't always believe that part, to which I usually say: the kids were five, for crying out loud. Five.)
In a country where nobody would dream of pulling public funding for studies into gun violence, the solution was amazingly rational and bipartisan. After a year, and an official inquiry into Dunblane, the Conservative government passed a sweeping piece of legislation restricting handguns. Then after Labour won the 1997 election, it passed another. Britain hasn't seen a school shooting since. (Same with Australia, which also passed major gun control legislation in 1996).
But trying to talk about all that in America over the last two decades, I've learned from experience, has been like touching the proverbial third rail: only tourists would be dumb enough to try it. Even gun control advocates now think they're dealing with an intractable, generational problem. Many tell me that we need to tackle mental health services or gun fetishization in Hollywood movies first. The legislation route couldn't possibly be that easy, they say.
But what if it isthat easy? What if the rest of the world also loves Hollywood action movies and has mental health problems, but manages to have fewer shootings simply because it has fewer guns available? What if the rest of the world has been shouting at America for years that gun control is less intractable than you think -- you just have to vote in large numbers for the politicians that favor it, and keep doing so at every election?
If that's the case, then perhaps some powerful, leveling international marketplace of ideas could help the U.S. see what everyone else has already seen. Something like social media.
Tweet may have been deleted
In one sense, Wednesday's massacre in Parkland, Florida -- a school shooting as shocking and senseless as Dunblane -- was evidence that America was further away from a gun control solution than ever. In 1996, buying an AR-15 assault rifle was illegal under federal law. Now, in Florida and many other states, a 19-year old can walk into any gun store and walk out with this military-grade weapon of mass destruction.
Yet anecdotally, I have noticed one glimmer of hope. Since the last American gun massacre that got everyone talking, there has been a small shift in the online conversation. It has become a little more global. The students of Parkland have been broadcasting to the world via social media, and the world is taking notice.
Tweet may have been deleted
I'm not suggesting some kind of slam-dunk situation where every American on Twitter and Facebook and Snapchat has an epiphany about gun control because they're more frequently interacting with people from other nations with different laws.
But I am saying it's noticeably harder for pro-gun accounts to spread lies about the situation in other countries without people from those countries chiming in.
Tweet may have been deleted
Meanwhile, there is a mountain of evidence that Russian bots and troll accounts are attempting to hijack the online conversation using the same playbook from the 2016 elections -- manufacture conflict to destabilize American discourse. That means taking the most trollishly pro-NRA position they can think of, in a bid to counteract the large majority of Americans who want sensible gun control.
So the voices from other countries are chiming in just in time. If anything, we need more of them to balance out cynical foreign influence in a pro-gun direction.
How effective gun control can happen
Twenty years of trying to have this debate in the U.S. have worn me down. As you might expect, I've been on the receiving end of a lot of Second Amendment-splaining from the pro-gun lobby. (Yep, I'm very familiar with the two centuries of debate over the militia clause, thanks.) I've been told I didn't understand the power of the NRA (which, again, I'm quite familiar with: the organization supported sensible gun restrictions until it was radicalized in 1977).
I've heard every argument you could imagine: the notion that British police must now be lording it over the poor defenseless population; the blinkered insistence that there must have been a rise in crime with illegal guns and legal knives now all the good people with guns have been taken out of the equation. (Violent crime is still too high in the UK, but it is a fraction of America's total -- and has declined significantly since 1996.)
I no longer have the dream that a UK-Australia-style handgun ban would work here. There are as many as 300 million firearms in private hands, according to a 2012 Congressional estimate; even though most of them are concentrated in the hands of a small percentage of owners, it's simply impractical to talk about removing a significant percentage of them from the equation.
But if anything, I'm more aware of creative legal solutions: laws that require gun insurance the way we require car insurance, or tax ammunition, or hold manufacturers responsible for gun deaths. I've seen my adopted state of California implement some of the toughest gun laws in the nation, laws that just went into effect. The fight to prevent future massacres is just getting started.
And any time you want to talk about how it can happen, the rest of a shrinking world is listening -- and ready to talk.
(责任编辑:新闻中心)
- South Korea beefs up drills amid escalating NK provocations
- German food showcased at KINTEX
- This is how badly we're managing our student debt
- Forgotten captives in North Korea
- Understanding Relational vs. Non
- [LLG] When compassion meets law: Lawyer defends goats, dogs, other helpless animals
- N. Korean threats impede Asian growth: Park
- N. Korean threats impede Asian growth: Park
- Here are Trump and Scaramucci's scenes from that Wall Street movie
- 21 Lost and Lonely Cemeteries
- Kickstarter opens in Asia, starting in Hong Kong and Singapore
- South Africa marks Freedom Day
- U.S. Vice President Joe Biden to speak at the 2016 Social Good Summit
-
Scientists discover where the huge dinosaur
A menacing asteroid, some six miles wide, triggered Earth's last mass extinction. Now, scientists ha ...[详细] -
Russia's appeal for security talks with N. Korea to counter Seoul
North Korean Foreign Minister Choe Son-hui (R) and her Russian counterpart, Sergei Lavrov, exchange ...[详细] -
Best Bose deal: Save up to $150 on Bose headphones and speakers
Best Bose DealsBest Bose Headphone DealBose QuietComfort headphonesq$249 at Bose(Save $100)Best Bose ...[详细] -
Unprecedented census confirms staggering decline in African elephant populations
While wildlife experts and advocates have long known elephants are in dire need of protection, essen ...[详细] -
CPUs Don't Matter For 4K Gaming... Wrong!
Something we hear a lot these days, especially when it comes to CPU benchmarking, is that CPU perfor ...[详细] -
S. Korea, Japan to hold defense ministers' talks next week
South Korean and Japanese defense chiefs will meet next week for the first time in four years amid s ...[详细] -
牧原5年狂掷41亿搞研发,海大研究生最多!你认为哪家企业最有前景?
牧原5年狂掷41亿搞研发,海大研究生最多!你认为哪家企业最有前景?_南方+_南方plus研发驱动未来,近年来越来越多的农牧企业重视自身研发能力。据统计,2023年17家农牧企业研发费用达50.5亿元, ...[详细] -
NK suspected in Sept. hack of decentralized finance project: report
GettyimagesbankNorth Korea is suspected of being behind a massive breach of a decentralized finance ...[详细] -
八仙帽精美的刺绣作品周学琼左)、唐伟欣右)在门口刺绣藏彝走廊东部边缘的石棉县,在横断山脉的褶皱、隆起与断裂,以及河流的急剧切割作用下,群山峡谷中藏着一个藏族秘境——蟹螺堡子。石头和泥土砌成的房屋展示着 ...[详细]
-
[Herald Interview] Educating girls ‘way to end poverty’
U.N. Women Executive Director Phumzile Mlambo-Ngcuka does not mince words when she talks about the e ...[详细]
- 两个改造提升项目进入收尾阶段
- Best headphones deal: The Sonos Ace are on sale for the first time ever.
- Increasing NK
- 荔枝+音乐,超赞!茂南乡村歌手唱响“爱的古荔”
- North Korea says it conducted important test to develop multiple warhead missile
- S. Korea should offer education expertise to poor nations: Julia Gillard
- Best Buy Drop of the day: 85