EU legal advisor backs UEFA over Super League
The European Court of Justice's top legal advisor said Thursday that football governing bodies UEFA and FIFA had acted within the law when they threatened to expel clubs or players who joined a proposed Super League.
The opinion of Advocate General Athanasios Rantos is not binding on the court, which is examining a complaint from the company that planned to run the new league, but it will be influential and taken as a sign of the direction the case is taking.
"EU competition rules do not prohibit FIFA, UEFA, their member federations or their national leagues from issuing threats of sanctions against clubs affiliated to those federations when those clubs participate in a project to set up a new competition," he wrote.
The court's final decision is not expected until early next year.
The position was immediately welcomed by FIFA and the Spanish La Liga as well as lobby groups representing European football clubs, leagues and supporters.
FIFA said it was happy Rantos had said it could "approve any new football competitions", that he had said it could impose sanctions and it "had exclusive rights to market" its international competitions.
FIFA also welcomed his recognition of "the special nature of sport."
The Spanish La Liga also welcomed the news.
"La Liga, along with other European leagues, will continue to fight for European institutions to legislate and provide legal protection for the current European model of soccer," said La Liga president Javier Tebas in a statement.
Fan association Football Supporters Europe said: "Last year, twelve obscenely wealthy clubs tried to destroy European football by creating a closed breakaway league.
"They failed because fans across the continent – including their own – stood in solidarity against their plans."
The European Club Association hailed Rantos' advice as "a clear rejection of the efforts of a few to undermine the foundations and historical heritage of European football for the many."
The attempt to set up an elite trans-European league in 2021, under the aegis of the European Super League Company (ESLC), initially attracted the support of some of the continent's biggest and richest clubs – but triggered a backlash from fans and governments.
The effort fell apart within 48 hours, but left behind bitterness and a key legal question.
The ESLC filed a complaint accusing UEFA, which regulates European football and organises the Champions League and Europa League, of "abusing its dominant position" in the market to squeeze out fair competition.
The eventual ruling will be keenly watched by teams and fans across Europe.
If the court follows its advisor's reasoning, the ESLC's challenge will fail.
"Whilst ESLC is free to set up its own independent football competition outside the UEFA and FIFA ecosystem, it cannot however, in parallel with the creation of such a competition, continue to participate in the football competitions organised by FIFA and UEFA without the prior authorisation of those federations," Rantos wrote.
A22 Sports Management, which says it was set up to sponsor and help bring about a Super League in Europe, responded with a press release.
"The Advocate General made clear that UEFA has a monopolistic position," it said, adding: "We believe the 15 judges of the Grand Chamber...will go substantially further and provide the opportunity for clubs to manage their own destiny in Europe."
European law generally protects commercial competition, but the advocate general found that the soccer governing bodies' threats "may be justified by legitimate objectives related to the specific nature of sport".
In the case of the short-lived super league initiative, this may be a moot point.
Initially it was supposed to create a competition for 12 clubs: Arsenal, Chelsea, Liverpool, Manchester City, Manchester United, Tottenham, AC Milan, Inter Milan, Juventus, Atletico Madrid, Barcelona and Real Madrid.
Fellow giants Paris Saint-Germain and Bayern Munich refused from the start to take part and the English clubs quickly distanced themselves from the plan in the face of fan fury.
UEFA imposed light fines on the nine clubs that dropped out, extracting a committment they would not try again, but Real Madrid, Barcelona and Juventus face a disciplinary inquiry that has been put on hold pending the legal ruling.
(责任编辑:新闻中心)
- The Analog Embrace: How Some Experiences Are Surviving the Digital Age
- TikTok will exit Hong Kong amidst controversial national security laws
- LIV Golf begins 2024 season with future at stake in merger talks
- Woman may face criminal charge for dancing naked in public
- When Are Next
- 科创筑梦树立远大志向 蓄势赋能培养科技人才
- Opposition parties call for government action amid North’s threats
- Cantlay says new PGA investors will help decide Saudi merger
- Norman says 'full steam ahead' as LIV season opens in Mexico
- A Barbie flip phone is here from HMD
- PGA Tour makes deal worth up to $3 bn to create for
- Norman says 'full steam ahead' as LIV season opens in Mexico
- 3人被杀 一人为8个月的婴儿
-
“至正七年置”青花纪年铭文盖罐1939年,梁思成考察测绘高颐阙 资料图片成都矛石羊上石兽一座古老城市的背后往往是一篇绵延的历史长诗,人类开始学会直立行走,同其他类人猿逐渐划分开伊始,部落、城邦在漫长的 ...[详细]
-
石棉县新棉镇长征路二段156号大院内,住着这样两户人家,一户是孤老张秀荣,一户是退休教师胡爱芬。他们不是亲人胜似亲人。照顾日常生活、给予经济帮助、带老人看病住院……十年如一日,胡爱芬对待张秀荣老人如同 ...[详细]
-
Ron Howard will finish directing Han Solo movie
Ron Howard is going to go see a Star War.He has been set as the new director of the Star WarsHan Sol ...[详细] -
Russian scientists pack more power into nuclear battery prototype
Imagine only replacing the batteries in a device once a decade, or even once a century. Nuclear batt ...[详细] -
Garmin Fenix 8 vs. Apple Watch Ultra: The Fenix wins big on battery life
Garmin's got a new flagship in its rugged smartwatch category, the Garmin Fenix 8. The company's Fen ...[详细] -
Apple's Big Sur macOS update adds big Safari redesign, Messages tweaks
Big Sur.Yes, that's the name of the next version of Apple's macOS. Whether you love or hate the name ...[详细] -
It's Apple's Worldwide Development Conference (WWDC) day today, and the company is widely expected t ...[详细]
-
Senior diplomats of S. Korea, US hold phone talks to discuss alliance, NK issues
Senior diplomats of South Korea and the United States have held telephone talks to discuss bilateral ...[详细] -
NYT mini crossword answers for August 29
The Mini is a bite-sized version of The New York Times' revered daily crossword. While the crossword ...[详细] -
EpiC MeMe PoSTer Elon Musk promises to ditch legacy blue checks on 4/20. Twitter rolls eyes.
Elon Musk — chief Twit and PoStEr oF EpiC MemEs that peaked in 2013 — claimed he would a ...[详细]
NASA says Earth just had the hottest day ever recorded
Samsung's new UV device charges and disinfects your phone
- 'Metaphor: ReFantazio' hands
- Best deals of the day March 29: SolaWave skincare wand, Shark self
- PGA Tour makes deal worth up to $3 bn to create for
- Nigeria and DR Congo win through to AFCON semi
- North Korea says it conducted important test to develop multiple warhead missile
- Samsung Galaxy Note 20 Ultra specs revealed in FCC listing
- 70万分之一 三胞胎早产 治疗费用高 愁坏两家人