Top court advises on sexual violence trials
2024-09-23 15:25:17 [资讯] 来源:Anhui News
The Supreme Court said Friday it overturned a lower court decision to reinstate a professor who was fired for sexually harassing students, saying it lacked sensitivity to gender equality.
The top court sent the case back to the Seoul High Court for retrial, and stressed that judges should apply gender sensitivity in handling cases of sexual wrongdoing, presenting a yardstick for future trials as the #MeToo movement sweeps the country.
Gender sensitivity refers to the aim of understanding societal and cultural factors involved in gender-based exclusion and discrimination.
The professor was dismissed from a provincial university in April 2015 on 14 counts of sexual harassment which included hugging a female student from behind and kissing a female student on her cheek while she was asleep during a class trip.
The professor took his case to the Appeal Commission for Teachers, calling for the cancellation of his dismissal. When his appeal was rejected, he filed a suit against the commission.
(Yonhap)
In the first trial, the court acknowledged all of the 14 harassment allegations as facts and ruled that his dismissal was legitimate as he could harass more students if he continued to work.
The appellate court, however, ruled in favor of the plaintiff, saying it was hard to validate some of the allegations since a purported victim did not mention the hugging in her anonymous evaluation of the lecture, and a student who was allegedly kissed did not bring it up for years until other victims asked her to.
In reversing the Seoul High Court’s decision, the Supreme Court warned that judges can be misled by stereotypes, and laid out guidelines for trials on sexual issues.
“It is the first court ruling that presented the legal principles for trial and judgment of evidence in sexual harassment lawsuits,” an official at the Supreme Court said.
“It is expected to serve as a key standard for judgment in future trials of sexual harassment cases.”
The Supreme Court said judges must bear in mind the possibility of secondary victimization of those who spoke out about sexual violence, and judge the victims’ statements with full consideration of the special circumstances they are in.
Judges must be mindful that victims often hesitate to reveal their experiences for fear of secondary victimization as their intentions can easily be misunderstood in a male-centric culture, the top court said.
The Supreme Court also advised judges to note that, fearing secondary victimization, victims often do not sever relations with the perpetrators, and speak out only after their crimes have been made public.
The top court said dismissing victims’ statements without fully taking into their particular circumstances runs against the notions of justice and equity.
By Kim So-hyun (sophie@heraldcorp.com)
The top court sent the case back to the Seoul High Court for retrial, and stressed that judges should apply gender sensitivity in handling cases of sexual wrongdoing, presenting a yardstick for future trials as the #MeToo movement sweeps the country.
Gender sensitivity refers to the aim of understanding societal and cultural factors involved in gender-based exclusion and discrimination.
The professor was dismissed from a provincial university in April 2015 on 14 counts of sexual harassment which included hugging a female student from behind and kissing a female student on her cheek while she was asleep during a class trip.
The professor took his case to the Appeal Commission for Teachers, calling for the cancellation of his dismissal. When his appeal was rejected, he filed a suit against the commission.
In the first trial, the court acknowledged all of the 14 harassment allegations as facts and ruled that his dismissal was legitimate as he could harass more students if he continued to work.
The appellate court, however, ruled in favor of the plaintiff, saying it was hard to validate some of the allegations since a purported victim did not mention the hugging in her anonymous evaluation of the lecture, and a student who was allegedly kissed did not bring it up for years until other victims asked her to.
In reversing the Seoul High Court’s decision, the Supreme Court warned that judges can be misled by stereotypes, and laid out guidelines for trials on sexual issues.
“It is the first court ruling that presented the legal principles for trial and judgment of evidence in sexual harassment lawsuits,” an official at the Supreme Court said.
“It is expected to serve as a key standard for judgment in future trials of sexual harassment cases.”
The Supreme Court said judges must bear in mind the possibility of secondary victimization of those who spoke out about sexual violence, and judge the victims’ statements with full consideration of the special circumstances they are in.
Judges must be mindful that victims often hesitate to reveal their experiences for fear of secondary victimization as their intentions can easily be misunderstood in a male-centric culture, the top court said.
The Supreme Court also advised judges to note that, fearing secondary victimization, victims often do not sever relations with the perpetrators, and speak out only after their crimes have been made public.
The top court said dismissing victims’ statements without fully taking into their particular circumstances runs against the notions of justice and equity.
By Kim So-hyun (sophie@heraldcorp.com)
(责任编辑:新闻中心)
相关内容
- Trump won't stop making a deceptive bird claim. Experts debunk it.
- A copy of the Jonas Brothers' 'Burning Up' ironically survived a house fire
- Meet Tango, the weirdest horse on Twitter
- Gov't asks S. Koreans to avoid trips near N. Korea amid terror threats
- The Techies Who Lunch
- How 3D Game Rendering Works: Texturing
- Amazon's Christmas tree delivery is great if you own a handsaw
- Amazon's Christmas tree delivery is great if you own a handsaw
- Lego and Amazon Alexa launch roleplaying Echo game for young builders
- 50 Places to Eat and Drink Before You Die
- The internet mocks Donald Trump's new superhero alter
- Lingard joins Nottingham Forest
- 6款作品获奖!北坡“最美游鱼”结果出炉
推荐文章
-
Spate of defections show Kim Jong
A new monument that commemorates North Korean defectors who have died while escaping from the repres ...[详细] -
This isOne Good Thing, a weekly column where we tell you about one of the few nice things that happe ...[详细]
-
雅安日报讯 元旦来临之际,为预防和遏制重特大火灾事故的发生,近日,武警雅安市消防支队组织全市消防力量,开展了一次突击检查。 当日晚,市消防支队检查组先后来到市区多家人员密集的娱乐场所进行消防安全突击 ...[详细]
-
雅安日报讯 昨14)日,市政协党组书记、主席傅克勤主持召开市政协二届三十九次主席会议,会议协商决定,市政协二届十三次常委会议于12月22日—23日召开。 会议讨论并原则通过了市政协二届十三次常委会议 ...[详细]
-
Military prosecutors indict intel official over leaking 'black agent' info
(Getty Images Bank)The defense ministry's prosecutors' office on Tuesday indicted a milita ...[详细] -
De Gea keen to extend Man Utd stay
MANCHESTER:Goalkeeper David de Gea said he hopes to remain at Manchester United and help the Premier ...[详细] -
S. Korean foreign minister, new USFK chief reaffirm strong alliance
South Korea's top diplomat and the new chief commander of U.S. troops in Korea on Wednesday reaffirm ...[详细] -
Fortnite and Stormy Daniels dominated Pornhub in 2018
Ah, December, a perfect time to sit back and reflect on what kind of porn you watched in 2018. Pornh ...[详细] -
The Analog Embrace: How Some Experiences Are Surviving the Digital Age
Zeroes and ones were promised to be the future, with digital media taking over in several ways. But ...[详细] -
5 easy tricks to make your iPhone storage last longer
With its non-expandable memory, one of the major bugbears for iPhone owners is the storage capacity. ...[详细]
热点阅读
随机内容
- The Best AMD Ryzen Gaming Laptops (So Far)
- All hail the drag Hormone Monstress dancing to 'bubble bath'
- Stephen King just demolished Donald Trump over his latest comments about the wall
- S. Korean foreign minister, new USFK chief reaffirm strong alliance
- PS5 Pro: There are new whispers that the release date is fast approaching
- Announcer sings 'Mr. Plow' song from 'The Simpsons' during Apple Cup blizzard
- Lewandowski, Benzema set for duel in Vegas 'Clasico'